MLB AI Picks April 5: Full Sunday Slate Board
Four AI models. 24 official picks across 11 games. Cubs F5 ML the lone 2/4 consensus. Three models on Yankees side.
Updated Standings (Through April 6 Grading, 12 Pending)
Lines - April 5, 2026 (Games With AI Action)
| Game | Fav ML | Dog ML | Total | AI Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PHI @ COL | PHI -175 | COL +144 | 11.5 | Claude (2), Grok |
| MIA @ NYY | NYY -275 | MIA +225 | 8.0 | Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini |
| NYM @ SF | SF -120 | NYM +100 | 7.0 | Claude (2), Grok, ChatGPT |
| LAD @ WSH | LAD -200 | WSH +165 | 8.5 | Claude, Grok |
| SEA @ LAA | SEA -155 | LAA +130 | 8.5 | Claude, Grok |
| PIT vs BAL | PIT -130 | BAL +110 | 8.5 | Claude |
| DET vs STL | DET -139 | STL +119 | 8.0 | Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini |
| CHC @ CLE (Gm 1) | CHC -130 | CLE +110 | 7.5 | Grok, Gemini |
| HOU @ OAK | HOU -126 | OAK +113 | 10.0 | ChatGPT, Grok |
| MIL @ KC | KC -125 | MIL +105 | 7.5 | ChatGPT |
| ATL @ ARI | ATL -110 | ARI -110 | 9.5 | Gemini |
Multi-AI Consensus (Same Exact Market, 2+ Models)
Only one true consensus play where multiple models picked the identical market. Sorted by vote count and total units.
2/4 Consensus
Same Game, Different Markets (Not True Consensus)
Picks With Opposing Views
Games where AI models are on opposite sides of the total or conflicting directions.
Current total is 8.0, so Claude's condition is met. Two models lean under vs one over. Gemini's F5 Under 4 is a different market (first half only) but aligns with the under side.
Game Under 7 could conflict with NYM team total Over depending on the number. Claude also has SF TT Under (1u) which aligns with the low-scoring thesis. ChatGPT has NYM ML (2u), a separate win/lose bet. Four different markets on the same game.
Individual AI Boards
Claude
9 Picks | 4-4-1 (-2.18u) | Season: 29-24-6-0.94u YTDGrok
6 Picks | 1-3-2 (-5.83u) | Season: 34-34-4-20.73u YTDChatGPT
5 Picks | 2-2-1 (-2.35u) | Season: 27-29-6-18.70u YTDGemini
4 Picks | 1-2-1 (-1.90u) | Season: 24-24-4-14.08u YTDBoard Notes
Only one true consensus: Cubs F5 ML in Game 1 of the CHC/CLE doubleheader is the sole 2/4 identical-market agreement (Grok 2.5u + Gemini 3u = 5.5u). This is a light consensus day.
Three models on the Yankees: Claude (F5 ML 1.5u), ChatGPT (run line -1.5, 2.5u), and Gemini (game Under 8, 2u) all touch NYY/MIA but from completely different angles. Not true consensus since the markets are different, but notable directional agreement favoring a dominant Yankees performance.
DET/STL split: ChatGPT takes the game Under 8 (1.5u) and Gemini takes F5 Under 4 (1u), while Claude goes the other way with game Over 8 (0.5u conditional). Two-to-one lean toward the under side.
NYM/SF four-way split: Four different plays from three models on the same game. Grok wants game Under 7 (2.5u). Claude wants NYM TT Over + SF TT Under. ChatGPT wants Mets ML. Each is a distinct market with distinct logic.
Claude's conditional plays: Two plays have conditions. PHI ML requires -240 or better (currently -175, well within range). DET/STL Over requires total of 9 or lower (currently 8.0, condition met). Both conditions are satisfied as of posting.
Grok's top play: Dodgers F5 ML at 3 units is the single biggest play on the board. Roki Sasaki on the mound in Washington is the angle.
PHI/COL total note: Grok's card listed Over 11 but the current line is 11.5. Posted at the current number. Line may have moved since Grok's card was generated.