Daily MLB Picks
Home › Picks record

MLB picks record: every daily card, graded

Each play from the daily cards, graded on the official final score from the MLB Stats API. Losses stay on the page. Nothing is removed or regraded.

Sep 18, 2026 to Sep 23, 2026 · 28 graded plays

16 wins, 12 losses, 0 pushes. +6.26 units on +7.61% return on risk.

By bet type

Bet typeWLPUnitsROI
Team total230−2.48−21.23%
Run line100+3.00+55.56%
Moneyline1130+19.30+40.64%
Game total250−8.08−66.07%
First 5 moneyline010−5.48−100.00%

By card

CardWLPUnitsROI
Sep 23, 2026220−6.00−56.23%
Sep 22, 2026230−2.78−28.08%
Sep 20, 2026520+5.98+26.77%
Sep 19, 2026320+5.00+27.31%
Sep 18, 2026430+4.06+19.28%

Every play

DatePlayPriceUnitsFinalResultNet
Sep 23, 2026Padres and Dodgers under 8.5 at Los Angeles−1101Padres 5, Dodgers 1WIN+1.00
Sep 23, 2026Atlanta Braves first 5 moneyline vs Reds−2742Reds 2, Braves 3LOSS−5.48
Sep 23, 2026New York Yankees moneyline vs Rays−1571Rays 2, Yankees 9WIN+1.00
Sep 23, 2026Washington Nationals team total under 3.5 at Detroit−1262Nationals 4, Tigers 2LOSS−2.52
Sep 22, 2026Los Angeles Angels moneyline at Athletics−1052Angels 7, Athletics 9LOSS−2.10
Sep 22, 2026Rays and Yankees under 6.5, Game 2 at Yankee Stadium−1151.5Rays 6, Yankees 1LOSS−1.73
Sep 22, 2026Boston Red Sox team total under 3.5 vs Guardians−1301Guardians 3, Red Sox 2WIN+1.00
Sep 22, 2026Brewers and Phillies under 7.5 at Philadelphia−1301.5Brewers 4, Phillies 6LOSS−1.95
Sep 22, 2026New York Yankees moneyline, Game 1 vs Rays−1412Rays 0, Yankees 2WIN+2.00
Sep 20, 2026Milwaukee Brewers moneyline at Orioles−2002.5Brewers 3, Orioles 0WIN+2.50
Sep 20, 2026New York Yankees moneyline at Diamondbacks−1081.5Yankees 4, D-backs 8LOSS−1.62
Sep 20, 2026Marlins/Padres under 8 at Petco Park−1202Marlins 3, Padres 7LOSS−2.40
Sep 20, 2026Braves/Astros under 8 at Daikin Park−1051Braves 4, Astros 2WIN+1.00
Sep 20, 2026Tampa Bay Rays moneyline vs Red Sox−1442Red Sox 1, Rays 5WIN+2.00
Sep 20, 2026Cleveland Guardians moneyline vs Athletics−2303Athletics 0, Guardians 1WIN+3.00
Sep 20, 2026Philadelphia Phillies moneyline at Mets−1661.5Phillies 7, Mets 2WIN+1.50
Sep 19, 2026San Diego Padres moneyline vs Marlins−1513Marlins 6, Padres 7WIN+3.00
Sep 19, 2026Blue Jays/Rangers under 7.5 at Globe Life Field−1102Blue Jays 2, Rangers 6LOSS−2.20
Sep 19, 2026Royals/Pirates under 8 at PNC Park−1201.5Royals 5, Pirates 6LOSS−1.80
Sep 19, 2026Cleveland Guardians moneyline vs Athletics−1773Athletics 6, Guardians 12WIN+3.00
Sep 19, 2026Tampa Bay Rays moneyline vs Red Sox−1493Red Sox 1, Rays 2WIN+3.00
Sep 18, 2026New York Yankees team total over 3.5 at Diamondbacks−1303Yankees 9, D-backs 2WIN+3.00
Sep 18, 2026New York Yankees moneyline at Diamondbacks−1102Yankees 9, D-backs 2WIN+2.00
Sep 18, 2026Seattle Mariners moneyline at Rockies−1812Mariners 5, Rockies 4WIN+2.00
Sep 18, 2026Atlanta Braves team total under 4.5 at Astros−1391.5Braves 6, Astros 2LOSS−2.08
Sep 18, 2026Toronto Blue Jays moneyline at Rangers−1321.5Blue Jays 1, Rangers 7LOSS−1.98
Sep 18, 2026Cleveland Guardians -1 vs Athletics−1803Athletics 3, Guardians 5WIN+3.00
Sep 18, 2026Kansas City Royals team total under 3.5 at Pirates−1251.5Royals 5, Pirates 8LOSS−1.88

How the grading works

Prices are the ones posted on each card. On a minus price the units are the amount to win, so a 2 unit play at −150 risks 3 units. On a plus price the units are the amount risked. Return on risk is net units divided by units risked on plays that won or lost.

Moneylines need a win. A run line of −1 wins by two or more runs and pushes on a one run win. A first 5 moneyline is graded on the score after five innings and pushes on a tie. Totals and team totals push only when the final lands exactly on a whole number. Postponed games are void.

Scores come from the MLB Stats API. This page rebuilds twice a day. Older pick history from the 2025 contest is on the AI contest page and the results page.